October 27, 2006
War of the Witches
Wulfila keeps serving up good stuff, this time a reflection on multiple religious identification as practiced in Latin America. His reflection is based on Timothy Knab’s War of the Witches, which has to do with contemporary practitioners of Aztec religion in Mexico, right alongside the practice of Catholicism. Wulfila comments:
…people [in Mexico] operate as orthodox Roman Catholics in one context, and in other contexts rely upon traditional beliefs and customs, but they don’t generally attempt to create a systematic theology that will reconcile both systems of beliefs or decide which one is “really” the true picture of the world – they just move from one language game to another in response to cues in their environment that tell them one heuristic will be more useful than another in diagnosing and curing their particular problem at the time. This may be somewhat unsatisfactory to someone of a more philosophical bent, but it seems like a very effective strategy for moving between radically different conceptual paradigms with minimal cognitive dissonance. In which case, the Midwestern Christian shaman would simply go back and forth between paradigms as needed, making no effort whatsoever to reconcile them.
Buddhism and Christianity certainly are radically different conceptual paradigms. Perhaps the effort to harmonize them (on which I spend rather too much time) is less useful then cultivating the fluidity and openness to migrate between paradigms with “minimal cognitive dissonance.”
I met a passionate researcher of the occult last year, Alfred Vitale (I have lost track of you, Alfred! but you can read one of his papers here). His notion is that occultism is the creative absorption and synthesis and re-expression of practices, beliefs, rituals, wisdom, from many disparate spiritual traditions. This idea stays with me as an evocative vision of the creative possibilities of spiritual experience (though the term “occult” sets off lots of “kingdom of the cults” alarm bells in my limbic brain).
Those of us out here on the edges, creatively synthesizing, whether we are “occultists” or “dual practitioners” or just playing with cognitive dissonance–maybe we need to get together. At that dinner I wrote of last night, one of my colleagues and I were scheming the creation of a “Checkered Career Club: the Association for People Who Don’t Belong to Any Associations”. This was in the context of sitting at table with a lot of library administrators and professors, and noticing that we didn’t have any such tidy professional identity on which we could hang our hat. But the notion is equally powerful, equally compelling, in the realm of religious identity. Occultists of the world, unite!
I’ll keep throwing out these manifesto-like phrases: perhaps someday they will coalesce into something substantial.
I am reading Shantideva’s Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life (the image to the left is for visual effect: my translation is Robert Thurman’s in
At the Lotus & Lily group meeting tonight something familiar happened: I walked in with my chin dragging the ground and my soul in a state of near-collapse, and walked out with a song in my heart and a spring in my step. Little sanghas, however humble, do seem to have that magical ability to keep one’s spirits up.
Maybe this isn’t quite enough reason to start a “famous Buddhist-Christians” list, but this little news tidbit from the New York Post is quite wonderful:

One of my fun Sunday afternoon hobbies is hunting through the CD bins at the mighty
On Saturday, November 4, Victoria and I will be offering a workshop called “Entering Sacred Time” at the Priory in Lacey (read more about it 
Comments(4)
Here’s